Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Trust

Through my little 19 years of life experience i have come to the conclusion that trust is a joke; i mean really. Maybe im just a little angry at the fact that me and my boyfriend are having major trust issues, but in general, it's really hard to trust anyone. In a world where it is so easy to lie to someone's face while they think your telling the truth, why not be dishonest? I treat others how i want to be treated and i don't do major lies, yet i seem to be getting lie after lie from a lot of people. I'm amazed at this. I'd rather hear the horrible truth from someone than have them lie to my face and keep me thinking everything is fine and dandy.
At the same time i feel like a hypocrite because (while thinking about how Mr.Mcardle told us to relate our blogs to english?) i remembered how i really liked the book a million little pieces, yet the man who wrote it lied and said it was a true story. Oprah was pretty upset about it but yet at the end of the day, it still was a really good book; lie or no lie. So my question is: why didn't he just tell the truth and say that it wasn't based on real events he went through? why did he have to lie about it? to make more money off of it and get more publicity? lameeeeee.

4 comments:

Casey McArdle said...

you make some good observations about lying and why people do it - i actually went to Denison with the author of a million little pieces - let me ask you this, if you didn't know that they were lies, would it matter? when you see a movie and it says "based on a true story" - does that make the movie mean more to you? to a degree, everything is fiction - our memory is imperfect - when james frey added all of those extra moments to his story, he was doing it to help explain what he was going through - i'm not defending him, just that when it comes to writing, it is imperfect - there is no true story - there is no true autobiography or true non-fiction - memory is imperfect, as we all are

lying on purpose via writing to help explain a point in a novel is different than someone lying to your face because of trust issues - frey may have exaggerated his memoirs in an effort to help people, but let me ask you this: which is better, lying to help people, or lying for your own benefit?

Sierra said...

I thought the book was really good and didnt care that he lied. I like books that have people with problems so either way i thought it was really good. I mean i do think that it makes it a lot more intriguing when he said that it was based on a true story because then people are more inclined to read it to see the struggle he had to go through. I do think you make a really good point about our memory being imperfect. I never thought of it that way.
And i do think that him lying to help other people is okay. As weird as that sounds. haha. I do have a question though, when u say that he was trying to help people, are u saying that in reference to the fact that he was showing people that he can get clean without going through the 12 steps? because i know some people are afriad of the religious side of it and probably would rather skip the 12 steps too.

Sarah p. said...

Your post reminds me of a song by Queens of the Stone age called 3's and 7's.
Lie, lie to my face
Tell me it ain't no thing
That's what I wanna hear
Take, your lie to the grave
That's what an old friend told me
Look what it did for him
The truth hurts so bad, wouldn't you say?
So why tell it?
If ignorance is bliss, then I'm in
Heaven now
Run, you'll never escape
You see, you'll go nowhere
Based on who you appear
Broke, laid to waste
Turn into sweet no-things
Kiss you goodbye
The truth hurts so bad, wouldn't you say?
So why tell it?
If ignorance is bliss, then I'm in
Heaven now
Keep going over and over again
The never ending places I've never been
No one is catching on
Callin' my bluff
The devil made me holier than I've ever been
What'd you do?
Say it with a smile, boy
Making us all forget
What'd you do?
Say it with a smile, boy
Making us all forget
Making us all forget
Making us all forget

People tell lies for two reasons...they love us and hurt us and don't want us to know, or they hate us... and want to hurt us.

now the only thing you have to figure out is which one is it.

Ryan said...

A good example of a "Based on a true story" movie is the Teaxas Chainsaw Massacre. This movie is based on a family who used human meat to make a chilli that they entered in to a contest at the fair each year. They won every year and some how were found out. So explain how the The Texas Chainsaw Massacre can be based on a true story? Lies in cases like this are made only for money and fame, much the same I believe as with the book you talk about.